Increase Font Size Option 5 Reset Font Size Option 5 Decrease Font Size Option 5
Home | Food | Groceries | Is Costco Cheap? 5 Reasons Not to Shop
In Southern California? Check out PulseLAfacebook_16 Facebook twitter_16 Twitter RSSRSS
 

Member Information






Forgot login?
Register
Is Costco Cheap? 5 Reasons Not to Shop Print E-mail
(41 votes, average 3.22 out of 5)
Food - Groceries
Written by livecheap staff   
Article Index
Is Costco Cheap? 5 Reasons Not to Shop
More Space Please
All Pages

It seems everywhere I go, I hear the same refrain, "Oh, you can get it cheaper at Costco!" It's enough to drive somebody like me to sign up for a lifetime super-platinum membership. But I won't. CostcoI don't shop there, and despite the throngs of Kirkland's Best cheerleaders that seem to surround me at nearly every gathering, I still don't want to shop at Costco. Even with my wife pushing me to bow to the enormous peer-pressure of every mini-van mommy friend of hers, I am not doing it. Here's 5 reasons why I don't shop at Costco and they have nothing to do with prices:

Time:

Nearly a decade ago, my wife and I had a Costco membership. We'd drive 10 miles through some of the most congested streets of Los Angeles, grab our cart and begin a lengthy shopping experience. The only place with worse traffic than Los Angeles is Costco. You'd show up on a Saturday or Sunday and consider yourself lucky to find a parking spot withing 500 feet of the entrance. We'd head up and down each aisle filling our massive cart(s) with every gargantuan jar of Mediterranean olives, twin pack of jumbo-sized Ketchup, and top it off with 10 pound packages of ground beef. When we finally finished loading our haul, we'd have to take our place in checkout lines that rivaled the lines at Disneyland. Add to the ordeal the commute back and the hour it would take to unload and pack away all the bounty, it would take four to five hours from the time we left until the last 24 pack of sandwich rolls was stashed away. Throw in the recovery time from a single Costco expedition and whatever day we shopped was written off.  The time suck alone was reason enough not to shop at Costco.

Spoilage:

Costco is cheap, but it can get awfully expensive if you don't consume your groceries before they go bad. We have a hard time keeping a 24 ounce loaf of bread from spoiling, but a 24 pack of rolls? Half of them never made it to the part of their life-cycle where they turn into a sandwich. I distinctly remember getting a 15 pound jar of fancy olives only to have 13 pounds go to waste. It seemed like such a great deal when we bought it, but we probably paid more per pound for those olives than any we've ever bought since. Costco has only two sizes: Mega-jumbo and super massive. Unless you have 3 sons on the high school football team or meticulously plan every meal around your food inventory, spoilage is going to be a major issue if you buy perishables at Costco. Cheap food at Costco isn't such a good deal when 20% of it ends up in the garbage can.

Grocery Stores are for FOOD!

Maybe I'm strange, but when I go shopping for food, I like thinking about...FOOD. Once in a while, I get distracted by the  flowers in supermarkets and fork over a few bucks to brighten the wife's day. But most of the time, I go straight for the food. One, thing I don't need is a weekly reminder of how cheap it can be to get buried in a Costco casket. There's nothing like strolling through the isles looking for Cheerios and finding them next to a display of Universal Caskets. I'll take a silver casket with my twin pack of milk please.

I also feel sorry for that poor guy that got his Costco card hoping to save a few hundred dollars a year on groceries only to shell out $8,000 for a "better" diamond engagement ring that his wife spotted at Costco. Yup, you can buy diamonds at Costco along with that casket.  Is there anything more financially ruinous than routinely exposing your wife to prominently displayed diamonds?

Of course, these are the extreme thing examples, but the point is Costco is not a supermarket - it's a mall loaded with non-food stuff that can make your shopping experience incredibly expensive when you fall into temptation and pick up an HDTV while shopping for baby diapers.



Comments
Add New RSS
+/-
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
jennifer  - costco is great - in moderation & under the right |2011-01-05 16:57:05
I will agree that there are things that you should never buy at costco, and location is everything. I drive by 2 on my way to & from work every day, and there is 2 more between my home and my mothers. I found that costco only makes sense for us with 3 conditions:
1 - I have the premier membership w/ 2% rewards, the rewards I receive every year more than pay for my membership. I gave my sister the second card on the membership, instead of my husband or mother, because she has a new baby - and lives 2 blocks from her costco. So I get 2% on everything she buys & everything I buy - then I do all of my office supply shopping for work online with my membership & the company credit card, i make my supply budget go farther and get 2% back the boss never knows about - bonus! Another nice thing about this is that card # 3 & on are only $40 per pair, so if you have family & friends that want in, you can add them to your account & save them money - then shop together & split the large packages!

2- I shop at the business center location. I like to shop at the business center for the best deals on food items with out having to sift through all the extra goodies that usually result in over spending, I'm usually in & out in minutes with just what i went in for. And they don't have the samples - if you can't taste it, you don't 'need' it... You do not have to have a business membership to shop at the business center, our location is focused on Gas Stations & Coffee Shops, so they have products that normal costco stores don't have, and case qty's of retail packaged items for often as much as 90% cheaper than your regular grocery store or M&P store.

3- Then once a month or so I take my mother, who is on state food stamps, to the costco near her in a city with a MUCH lower sales tax rate to stock her up on freezable & non perishable food items and both household's non food items like TP & cleaning supplies. When we buy in bulk like this we can split the bigger packages of perishables and not have the waste. This alone saves me over $50 a year just in sales tax!

Busymom25  - Ok, Costco is not that bad |2010-12-31 21:57:22
I have a Costco and Sam's cards, but in my house I have 1 daughter in highschool and 1 in college (she doesn't live here but is here every Sun for dinner). With my daughter in highschool I get the highschool football players in my house and yes they do eat alot, so do girls don't kid yourselfs that girls eat less than boys.
I do have a chest freezer and save alot of money by shopping in bulk. My family eats far better by buying in bulk and freezing than if I was buying store brands. Don't get me wrong I shop other stores too but Sams allows my food budget to go further.
Mimi  - I only have Costco membership cause of Ameriprise |2010-09-16 10:00:25
I only keep my Costco Membership cause of the great insurance Ameriprise they have, My husband & I save about $400 a year. I love their customer service. I had a car run into me while waiting to make a turn so not my fault but my car got damaged they asked for 3 estimates and the payed me in a week. Best service I have ever had with car insurance. I do use my membership for food but I really only keep it for car& home insurance.
Maureen  - Ameriprise Insurance |2010-10-09 13:02:53
I to have Ameriprise insurance but do not belong to Costco. We have some great investments with Ameriprise and that enables us to be insured with them.
Burt  - Warehouse stores rock!! |2010-09-08 13:09:52
Well, I don't shop at Costco either, because Sam's Club is WAY cheaper on most things, and it's really, REALLY easy to shop smart there. With a business membership (easy to do), I go there at 7:00 AM Saturday (nobody there except cashiers), get what I need in 20 minutes, save 30% every visit, and off I go. Well worth the annual membership.
Candace  - Learn to Shop Costco |2010-09-07 15:12:24
Just like any other store you need to shop smart. Yes, Costco is crazy on the weekend (not just in CA - we're in TX) - which is why we shop during the week. Our favorite way is to meet on our lunch hour, shop, then hit the snack bar for a $4 costco date. My husband works from home so he can take our haul back with him. Yes, there are some items your family won't use up before they spoil - don't buy those items. And while it is handy to have a big freezer, the SUV is definitely not required. I do most of my Costco runs in an MG - the only thing I have to skip is buying the mega-pack of toilet paper:)
Kered Retej |2010-09-07 13:52:53
I think the calculus changes when you live 2.2 and 2.8 traffic-free miles away from the two nearest Costcos.

Second, I think your California location skews your view of the insane parking and checkout lines (especially on weekends). I think that Costco locations located elsewhere in the country are often much less crowded.

Third, one of the things I like about Costco is they seem to turn their inventory over very quickly, which means the grocery items (meat/produce) always seem pretty fresh (though you still have the quantity/spoilage problem).

Last, if you live close to one that has a gas station (as I do), you might save enough in gas alone to justify the membership fee and the trips.
Ducklady  - Want fresh? |2010-09-09 17:25:41
Buy local. It doesn't get any fresher than picked/milked/gathered today.

And it's not as expensive as people think. I went to the USDA website the other day and discovered buying almost exclusively from local farmers puts my family smack in the middle of their cost range. And we eat well, very well. Everything is fresh, local and delicious.

We went to Walmart when it first came to the nearest big city. Once. We got home $84 poorer because everything was "such a good deal." I looked at the stuff when we got home (and the magic wore off) and said "I know a better way to save money. Don't go to those big stores. You won't spend $84 on stuff you really don't need."

I totally agree with this article. Well, except for the swipes at my gender, thank you. I have no interest in diamonds. The casket, though. That might do the trick.
Omiewon  - Thanks Ducklady |2010-09-09 22:10:05
Admittedly, the diamond part was added as a little humor that probably didn't sit well with some and I apologize. HDTVs would have been my poison as I resisted them for years when they first came out at Costco and they cost a fortune.

The caskets (which are a display not real in store caskets) just don't sit well with me. I know they probably make a lot of money, but they just seem out of whack.

I think your point is a great one. You can get a lot of "great" deals but if you spend more money than you should have, you still overspent.
Mark Parkins  - What a Costco clerk told me |2010-09-07 10:47:27
When I complained to a Costco clerk that I could find lots of cheaper tires at Discount or Big-O, he explained to me that Costco's strategy is the have cheaper prices on PREMIUM merchandise - in my case tires like Michelin - not simply the lowest prices overall. Sometimes I'm really not looking for the big name brands - I tend to think they are more hype than real value.
Jaynee  - Time vs. money |2010-09-07 09:04:47
If you look at Costco solely in regards to price, there are only a few items that I find are better than our locally owned/operated grocery store. For those items (milk, salad, eggs, etc.) I will make the twice a month trip to Costco. Yes, I completely agree that the parking and checkout lines are horrific. But, getting the few items that I need, I can get in and out in around 20 minutes.
Jo  - Value - added |2010-09-07 08:17:15
I find that Costco has value-added merchandise. What does that mean? I went shopping for a new digital camera. Every store had it for around the same price as did Costco. Except - they had a leather case (which cost $40 at Best Buy) and an extra SD card. When I bought my sons their DS Lites 2 years ago, they each got a car charger with the case for the same price as a regular store without the extras. Yes, I agree, when I buy the big pack of bread(or hummus, cheese, lettuce, fruit. etc.) I have to make sure we're going to use it. There are times when I won't go to Costco for 2 or 3 months at a time. But if you buy what you need and are smart about it, you will get more value for your money. Milk is much cheaper there and it is sold by the gallon, toys have "extras" that you can't get in a regular store even though they are the same price. I could go on and on. Know your prices and you can get a good deal.
Bev Sinks  - Amusing but exaggerated |2010-09-07 04:45:17
Well yes, if you have to drive a long distance, this is going to take some time. But why do you have to resort to exaggeration? a 15 lb can of olives. Oh please. I have two jars downstairs, each 1.25 lbs. The large can holds far less than 15 lbs. A LOT less.

Rather than eschew Costco, why not learn to shop. Go there for the values, shop wisely, stick to your list and don't browse.

Women and diamonds - oh come on now......
Omiewon  - The Olives Were For Real |2010-09-07 10:37:41
Bev,
I thank you for the comments, but the jar was actually 15lbs. This wasn't a run of the mill regular jar, it was enormous. It held over 2 gallons as we later found out when we re-used it for beverages. I'd take a picture of it, but it broke a few years ago. My wife and I thought it was the most incredible deal, but the olives were only so-so and the vast majority of it went bad.

I kinda expected this reaction to this article because our friends that go to Costco have an almost cult-like following of the store.
Lom |2011-12-13 17:59:19
Omiewon, you obviously have not been near a Costco for years. I just renewed my membership after several years and found it to be completely different than what I remember as far as size of products. Yes, they have many things that are huge, but they also have their products in the sizes that regular grocery stores carry, and there is a lot more variety. The meat and fish ARE cheaper and there are things there that I just can't find in other stores. As far as the lines, they move fast and it is no big deal. It does not take four or five hours unless you are moving like a turtle. I like it when they give out samples. There are a few things I have bought just because the sample is so good. You may not think you are missing out, but you are.
 
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack